The Linux Desktop and Computer-Aided Engineering
Is the Linux desktop ready for Computer-Aided Engineering (CAE)? Or, more aptly, is CAE ready for the Linux desktop?
Linux vs Windows
Debate has raged over whether the Linux desktop is ready for prime-time to take on the mighty Microsoft Windows franchise. But there is little debate over the fact that the Linux operating system (OS) is now a mature and stable platform, as its dominance in High-Performance Computing (HPC) clusters and web servers demonstrates. The latest versions of the 2 main Linux desktop window managers, GNOME and KDE, offer good GUIs that are the equal to anything on Windows.
The productivity tools available under Linux, such as office applications (e.g., OpenOffice) and web browsers (e.g., Firefox), are also competitive in features to those offered under Windows. The Linux advantage is compelling when you consider that most of these desktop applications are free. This fact has not been lost on some European and Asian government agencies that are now moving over to the Linux desktop.
For the creative types out there, Linux offers GIMP, Inkscape and Blender that are good alternatives for Photoshop, CorelDraw and 3ds Max. And, for those precious leisure hours, Linux has the full gambit of casual games, such as Mahjongg. The only real weakness that Linux suffers is a lack of the latest 3D games, where it is a poor cousin to the games consoles and Windows.
3D accelerated graphics was a Linux weakness, but not anymore. The big 2 graphics card chip suppliers, ATI and Nvidia, have made big strides in supplying reliable drivers for Linux.
CAE Under Linux
So how does Linux fare in the CAE arena? The are vendors that offer Linux versions of their software, such as ALGOR and ANSYS, but there are many more that don't. The big CAD players such as AutoCAD and Solidworks only support Windows. At one time a lonely CAE application on Linux without office productivity tools for writing reports was hard to justify, but not any more. As we've seen, the productivity tools available for Linux are the match of any on Windows. Now an engineer can perform an entire project using Linux as long as the CAE tools are there too.
Of the CAE vendors that do offer CAE tools for Linux many still use clunky installers that only support 'official Linux distros' (read Redhat and SUSE) and even then don't integrate with the leading desktop managers by associating their application with their native file types and providing a launch menu. The look and feel of these CAE applications typically mimics a time when Motif was the leading GUI standard - enough said. Then there's the license manager setup and configuration, which is another painful experience no matter what platform you find yourself on.
There is another way and it comes from using the latest development tools. A cross-platform GUI toolkit that supports the native GUI controls of the underlying desktop manager, such as wxWidgets, ensures that the same code base can serve multiple platforms and maintain the latest native look and feel. Autopackage is a modern Linux installer (and uninstaller) with a Windows-like GUI that provides file associations and application menu entries for either KDE or GNOME, without locking you into a specific Linux distro.
We, here at Symscape, believe that there are compelling reasons to consider Linux for CAE and we will shortly release a native Linux version of Caedium and its add-ons (e.g., Caedium Professional) using wxWidgets. Caedium will also use the Autopackage installer so you can expect an easy setup, integration with either the KDE or GNOME desktops, and an automated update process. Oh yeah, and no license manager process to configure.
So is the Linux desktop ready for CAE? Most definitely, yes.
Is CAE ready for Linux? I can't speak for the rest of the industry, but here at Symscape we are ready - just watch this space.
Recent blog posts
- Remote CFD is Easy
- CFD Simulation of Airflow Through Filters in a Dust Collector
- CFD Analysis of a Homemade Cyclone
- CFD Analysis of a Blower for a Small Dust Collector
- Fluid Device Design is Like Herding Cats So Let CFD Help
- Reduced Complexity 3D Models for CFD
- 2014: A Year in CFD Simulations
- 7 Ideas For Your Year Ahead in CFD
- CFD Doodle: Multiple Interconnected Snow Globes
- Not All CFD GUIs Are Created Equal